Obelisk Art History
Themes in Art

Framed Artwork
Where did all the frames go?

Framed Artwork, Themes in Art

Most of Obelisk’s images of artwork don't include the frame. The majority of my sources for artwork imagery: museum archives, Google Art Project, WikiCommons, etc, default to frameless images, I assume because professional photography of 2d artworks usually happens when a painting is being refurbished or documented, behind the scenes, removed from their display frames. Shooting this way is much easier, and lends itself to a better image. You can often tell when an artwork was photographed in a frame that was later cropped out by the dark shadow running around the edges of the image, not to mention that frames often hide a centimeter or so around the edge of the artwork.

Of course, there’s more to the death of the frame than convenience. I suspect the frameless default reflects a contemporary bias towards the ‘pure’ presentation of art—that artwork is best seen in a white box, with no context, and similarly, minimal framing, if any all. Frames, especially the giant gold ones that populate the premodern wings of every art museum ever, are ostentatious to the modern eye. Tacky. Gouche. A distraction from the photonic communication from the artist to the viewer, a tasteless wrapper of exclusivity and wealth.

I understand this bias, and feel it myself. I love looking at the smooth gradients of a Turner seascape or Velázquez’s trademark crimson in the disembodied void of a minimalist website. White background or charcoal grey, smooth, featureless, perhaps the lightest of dropshadows to lift the image into dimensionless space. No distractions. I've personally cropped out dozens of frames if not hundreds, cursing their intrusive shadows and delicately lightening image edges in a dubious attempt at digital restoration.

This is, of course, a tragedy. For centuries framing has been a fascinating and deep discipline with it’s own fashions, trends, techniques and philosophies. It is the art that art lives in, the clothes the paintings wear. The style and craft of a painting’s frame holds invaluable information about how the culture that owns the art, thinks about it. For example, the simple, somber portraits of 17th century puritans were framed in simple black wood, a direct rejection of the flamboyant gilded filagrees that wreathed the icons of Roman Catholic saints. Frames are a dialog happening in parallel to the artwork.

I hope, someday, to dig deeply into the history of framing artwork, but until then, I recommend visiting the brilliant and impossibility deep rabbit hole that is The Frame Blog, a long-running blog and research partnership between historian and archivist Lynn Roberts and the National Gallery of London. Incredible stuff, definitely check it out. And below, you can find those rare selections of the Obelisk library that have retained their frames—from the beaded and columned mounting of the Fiesole Altarpiece to Florine Stettheimer’s trumploi curtains pulled back to reveal the scene, to a Frida Khalo self-portrait ringed with mirrors that confront the viewer with their own gaze—these frames are often incorporated into the artwork to the point where they are inseparable.


...


Got questions, comments or corrections about Framed Artwork? Join the conversation in the Obelisk chat room, and if you enjoy content like this, consider becoming a member to unlock exclusive essays, downloadables, and discounts at the Obelisk Store.

Reed Enger, "Framed Artwork, Where did all the frames go?," in Obelisk Art History, Published July 13, 2022; last modified July 13, 2022, http://arthistoryproject.com/subjects/frames/.

Read More
A Cuca, Tarsila do Amaral

A Cuca

Tarsila do Amaral, 1924
Altarpiece of Santa Reparata — Back, Giotto di Bondone

Altarpiece of Santa Reparata — Back

Giotto di Bondone, 1310
Altarpiece of Santa Reparata — Front, Giotto di Bondone

Altarpiece of Santa Reparata — Front

Giotto di Bondone, 1310
Badia Polyptych, Giotto di Bondone

Badia Polyptych

Giotto di Bondone, 1300
Beauty Contest: To the Memory of P.T. Barnum, Florine Stettheimer

Beauty Contest: To the Memory of P.T. Barnum

Florine Stettheimer, 1924
Bird in Motion, Fortunato Depero

Bird in Motion

Fortunato Depero, 1916
Black and White II, Charles Alston

Black and White II

Charles Alston, c. 1960
Blessing of the Tuna Fleet at Groix, Paul Signac

Blessing of the Tuna Fleet at Groix

Paul Signac, 1923-1923
Cards and Dice, Georges Braque

Cards and Dice

Georges Braque, 1914
Dancer = Propeller = Sea, Gino Severini

Dancer = Propeller = Sea

Gino Severini, 1915
Dynamism of a Dog on a Leash, Giacomo Balla

Dynamism of a Dog on a Leash

Giacomo Balla, 1912
Fiesole Altarpiece, Fra Angelico

Fiesole Altarpiece

Fra Angelico, 1424-1425
From Spaniard and Morisca, Albino Girl, Miguel Cabrera

From Spaniard and Morisca, Albino Girl

Miguel Cabrera, 1763
Fulang-Chang and I, Frida Kahlo

Fulang-Chang and I

Frida Kahlo, 1937-1939
Hommage to Velazquez, Mersad Berber

Hommage to Velazquez

Mersad Berber, 1999
Horse and Boy, Mersad Berber

Horse and Boy

Mersad Berber, c. 1992
Judith and the Head of Holofernes, Gustav Klimt

Judith and the Head of Holofernes

Gustav Klimt, 1901
Madame X, John Singer Sargent

Madame X

John Singer Sargent, 1883
Madonna and Child, Luca della Robbia

Madonna and Child

Luca della Robbia, 1475
Marlboro, Richard Hambleton

Marlboro

Richard Hambleton, 1984
Nativity, Luca della Robbia

Nativity

Luca della Robbia, 1460
Portrait of Alexander A. Knox, Thomas Woolner

Portrait of Alexander A. Knox

Thomas Woolner, 1859
Saint Francis Receiving the Stigmata, Lorenzo Monaco

Saint Francis Receiving the Stigmata

Lorenzo Monaco, 1420
Self Portrait, Anthony van Dyck

Self Portrait

Anthony van Dyck, 1640-1641
Sphinx, Franz Stuck

Sphinx

Franz Stuck, 1904
Spiritual (Study of a Negro Head), Gluck (Hannah Gluckstein)

Spiritual (Study of a Negro Head)

Gluck (Hannah Gluckstein), 1927
St. Sebastian Aided by St. Irene, Trophime Bigot

St. Sebastian Aided by St. Irene

Trophime Bigot, 1640
More Themes in Art
Gardens, Themes in Art

Gardens

Spend some time in a quiet place

Still Lifes, Themes in Art

Still Lifes

Quiet moments with simple objects

Ancient Classics, Themes in Art

Ancient Classics

A good story never gets old

Obelisk uses cookies to measure site usage, helping us understand our readers' interests and improve the site. By continuing to browse this site you agree to the use of cookies. Cookie Policy