Artists who Died Young

— Why do great artists die young?

It's a nearly mythological phenomenon. A young creative genius takes the world by storm. Their artwork, music, poetry—it's raw. Unfiltered. The strength of their message, their confusion, energy, love and pain jump into our hearts. Then they overdose, die of illness, or take their own life. In music they call it the 27 club, of which Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin and Kurt Cobain are members, and the art world has its own list of young artists snatched by death.

Gothic engraver Aubrey Beardsley died at 26 of tuberculosis. Gifted 16th century painter and art teacher Elisabetta Sirani wasted away from peritonitis at 27. Eva Hesse gave objects new lives in sculpture and was killed by a brain tumor at 34. And there are many more.

So what's going on? Does creativity kill?

Theories abound, and even a few scientific studies tackle the subject. Mark Bellis and his team at the Centre for Public Health in Liverpool studied the mortality of rock and pop stars, finding that one year after 'making it big' the survival rate for North American pop stars was 12.4% lower than the general population. But the crux of Bellis's research measured the impact of fame, and the risk-taking and illicit substances it often includes. Some of our artists lived fast and died understandably young (we're looking at you Caravaggio), what about the artists who weren't famous in their lifetimes?

Career coach Todd Brison offers another explanation: that artists don't die younger than most people, we just remember the ones that do. Brison points to our innate fear of death as the source of our fascination with artists dead in their prime. He also cites a form of psychological bias known as the Isolation Effect, where humans will remember the outlier from a list of similar items, and speculates that death inflates our sense of an artist's value, similar to JFK's current 90% approval rating among Americans.

But the art market may not support Brison's theory. The so-called 'death effect' claims that an artist's death marks the end of their artistic production, and scarcity will increase the value of their work. But in their book The Economics of American Art, researchers Ekelund and Jackson measure the death effect, and discover that it only appears for living artists, in the five years leading up to the artist’s death. Essentially, when the art market thinks you're about to die there's an increased interest in your work, but after you're dead, demand returns to normal.

Of course, the theory that many creative people secretly worry about is that the creative act itself is so taxing that artists literally destroy themselves to create art. That stress, self-doubt, and the torture of never quite being able to manifest your visions destroys your immune system and erodes your mental stability, leaving artists vulnerable to disease and suicide. And wouldn't you know, this might be true.

A study of suicides in the UK from 2011-2015 by the UK Office for National Statistics, and a concurrent study in the U.S. by the Center for Disease Control found that people who work in arts-related jobs are up to four times more likely to commit suicide than the national average. Unsurprisingly, these studies led to an explosion of alarmist articles on their release in 2017. But the sensational headlines left out a crucial detail, that other, non-arts professions had similar suicide rates. Among men, construction and mining jobs had higher suicide rates than jobs in the arts, and among women—police officers, service industry and healthcare workers had similarly high suicide rates. Which begs the questions, is it creativity that kills, or professions that lack upward mobility, robust retirement and health plans, and require long hours?

With so many interlacing theories, we may never have a conclusive word on whether artists die young more often than the rest of us. But for now, it looks like we're safe to pick up the brush, dust off the pastels and let our creativity loose. Just remember to take care of yourself, be patient as you learn, and take your vitamins.

Read More
Portrait of Amedeo Modigliani

Amedeo Modigliani

1884-1920
Portrait of Amrita Sher-Gil

Amrita Sher-Gil

The truncated lives of women

1913-1941
Portrait of Ana Mendieta

Ana Mendieta

1948-1985
Portrait of Antonio Sant'Elia

Antonio Sant'Elia

Prophet of the violent, industrial future

1888-1916
Portrait of Aubrey Beardsley

Aubrey Beardsley

"If I am not grotesque I am nothing"

1872-1898
Portrait of Caravaggio

Caravaggio

How a murderer invented Baroque painting

1571-1610
Portrait of Cristóbal Rojas Poleo

Cristóbal Rojas Poleo

A childhood introduction to death leads to success, at a price

1857-1890
Portrait of Edward Saidi Tingatinga

Edward Saidi Tingatinga

Father of a dynasty of Tanzanian painters

1932-1972
Portrait of Egon Schiele

Egon Schiele

Genius dead at 28

1890-1918
Portrait of Elisabetta Sirani

Elisabetta Sirani

The mysterious death of a young art teacher

1638-1665
Portrait of Eva Hesse

Eva Hesse

Living materials

1936-1970
Portrait of Genevieve & Virginia Jones

Genevieve & Virginia Jones

Even death will not stop us

1847-1879
Portrait of George Bellows

George Bellows

1882-1925
Portrait of Georges Seurat

Georges Seurat

Manipulating emotion with color

1859-1891
Portrait of Giorgione

Giorgione

Rich color and mood like smooth syrup

1477-1510
Portrait of Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec

Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec

Too many prostitutes and too much absinth

1864-1901
Portrait of Hishida Shunsō

Hishida Shunsō

A quiet boy paints cats in a new style

1874-1911
Portrait of Lee Jung-seob

Lee Jung-seob

A life of longing

1916-1956
Portrait of Liubov Popova

Liubov Popova

We shall remake the world

1889-1924
Portrait of Marie Bashkirtseff

Marie Bashkirtseff

"To live so filled with ambition, and at the end, oblivion!"

1858-1884
Portrait of Olga Rozanova

Olga Rozanova

The intellectual mother of Abstract Expressionism

1886-1918
Portrait of Paula Modersohn-Becker

Paula Modersohn-Becker

Why do Expressionists die young?

1876-1907
Portrait of Raphael Sanzio

Raphael Sanzio

Star boy parties himself to death

1483-1520
Portrait of Robert Smithson

Robert Smithson

Relationships with physical landscape

1938-1973
Portrait of Tshibumba Kanda-Matulu

Tshibumba Kanda-Matulu

Who carries the memory of the people?

1947-1981
Portrait of Ülo Ilmar Sooster

Ülo Ilmar Sooster

A bad time to be an artist in the Baltics

1924-1970
Portrait of Umberto Boccioni

Umberto Boccioni

Why can’t I stop painting my mother?

1882-1916
Portrait of Vincent Van Gogh

Vincent Van Gogh

Eloquent writer forges new path in painting

1853-1890
More Themes in Art

Cuneiform

Cities

Hustle and grind

Abstract Figures

Hinting at the human form

Obelisk uses cookies to measure site usage, helping us understand our readers' interests and improve the site. By continuing to browse this site you agree to the use of cookies. Learn more